The Real Housewives of New York City is back and spicer than ever!

During Tuesday’s season 15 premiere of the hit Bravo show, Brynn Whitfield found herself in the hot seat when her fellow housewives Sai de Silva and Erin Lichy confronted her for “manipulating” what was meant to be a funny “light hearted” story about Jenna Lyons‘ car troubles.

While getting lunch with Ubah Hassan and newcomer Rebecca Minkoff, Erin recalled seeing the rest of the housewives at a small gathering at Jenna’s apartment. It was there that Brynn allegedly accused Erin of calling the former J. Crew creative director “poor” when she had to call Jenna a $250 Uber ride back to the city. While getting lunch together in the Hamptons, Jenna’s vintage car had broke down and Erin was never reimbursed for the ride.

Brynn, however, told a “whole other version” of the story where Erin claimed Jenna was having “money problems” and couldn’t get herself a ride back home.

In a conversation with cameras, Erin denied Brynn’s recollection of the events and instead claimed she was trying to bring “levity” to the situation and retell it in a “funny” way.

“I am fully aware that Jenna, in her $10 million loft and her $5 million beach house, does not have money problems,” she explained.

Later in the episode, Jenna and Jessel Taank rehashed the events with Brynn while furniture shopping. Jenna revealed that she and Erin had a conversation to clear the air where she denied ever saying the fashion icon was going through financial hardship.

“Okay so we just made up a lie?” Brynn scoffed before Jenna recalled feeling “disappointed” and “bummed that this went down.”

“Erin was like, ‘I swear it didn’t go down that way.’ I’m like, what am I gonna do?” she said in a confessional. “There’s two sides of the story. Everyone is a gossip. No one gets a happier life.”

Erin, on the other hand, theorized that Brynn’s anger was displaced and she was trying to “get back at me” for her latest appearance on SiriusXM’s Jeff Lewis Live. When the host asked if Brynn had ever slept with anyone for money, Erin denied knowing anything about her finances and played too coy for Brynn’s liking.

More drama ensued when the entire group reunited for drinks at a New York City club. Erin wasn’t the only one who had issues with Brynn, tension between her and Sai only grew after Jenna claimed Brynn told her Sai had been talking “s—” about her behind her back.

Sai and Jenna were able to put water under the bridge, but her rift with Brynn only grew wider. She told cameras, “Brynn is doing what Brynn does, and she can’t stand if anyone in this friendship group gets close to one another. She needs to stir the pot, sprinkle some little bulls— in it, and then feed it to all of us so we don’t get along.”

As Erin, Jessel and Jenna tried to clear the air about who called who “poor,” Brynn joined the conversation, which triggered an audible “ugh” of disgust from Erin. Just moments before, Erin had called Brynn a “liar” and accused her of “manipulating” the details.

“I get hurt because I actually cared about you, you’re like a bad friend,” Erin told Brynn, who called her out for “saying stuff that’s not true about me and my character” during her appearance on Lewis’ show.

Sai also took the opportunity to join the fold and accused Brynn of having a problem with Jenna and Erin growing closer. She recalled walking into Jenna’s home and feeling “the biggest tension ever” after Brynn told Jenna that Erin had called her poor. Brynn denied this and claimed that things turned “weird” after Sai told Jessel, “F— you, Jessel and your Dory from Finding Nemo look alike husband.”

“You are a f—ing gaslighting, narcissist f—ing asshole. I love the way you switch this s— up. I’m talking about you and you’re talking about the s— I said to Jessel?” Sai seethed before telling cameras that she and Jessel were in a “good place” and Brynn was “deflecting.”

“You are unwell Brynn,” Sai huffed before ending the conversation. “Not today, Satan. Not today, Satan. I won’t do it.”

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

The Real Housewives of New York City airs Tuesdays at 9 pm ET on Bravo.